Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Alicia Andrews Gets 15 Years After Manslaughter Conviction in Foolio Case
Alicia Andrews was sentenced to 15 years in prison on May 22 after a manslaughter conviction in the killing of rapper Foolio. Judge Kimberly Fernandez denied an appeal motion; Foolio’s mother delivered a forceful victim impact statement. Four co-defendants face June 22 sentencing.
By the time the clocked benches of the Tampa courtroom emptied on Friday, the trial that splintered social feeds and neighborhood storefront conversations reached a single, hard line: Alicia Andrews will spend 15 years behind bars.
The sentence, handed down on May 22, closes one chapter of a case that has been as much about public grief and spectacle as it has been about legal process. Cameras and courtroom observers had followed the proceedings since the indictment, and Friday’s hearing felt like the thud of consequence after weeks of testimony, surveillance footage and witness statements.
Judge Kimberly Fernandez moved quickly through a motion to appeal and, after dismissing Andrews’ arguments, pronounced the sentence. In court she echoed her review of the record with a curt refusal to overturn what a predecessor judge had handled.
“After having reviewed all of the defense’s assertions as to the defense’s argument as to errors made by my predecessor judge, I’m going to place on the record that I would not have ruled any differently.”
The legal designation for Andrews’ conviction was manslaughter, not first-degree murder, and that distinction is reflected in the 15-year term. In the gallery, supporters and relatives watched in silence; outside the courthouse, conversations quickly returned to larger questions about accountability and violence in and around rap scenes.
Foolio’s mother, Sandrikas Mays, used her victim impact statement to give the court specific portraiture of loss and frustration. She recounted surveillance and messages that, in her telling, made her son’s death look methodical rather than accidental. Her voice in the courtroom — low, precise — cut through the procedural language of the day.
“My son was hunted, followed and ultimately murdered in what authorities described as a coordinated plot involving multiple individuals. It is extremely painful to hear Alicia Andrews portray herself as someone who didn’t know what was going on. They could have turned around, but they still carried on the plan to hunt my son down like a deer in the woods…My son’s life mattered. He was not disposable.”
Elsewhere in the case, four co-defendants — Sean Gathright, Isaiah Chance, Rashad Murphy and Davion Murphy — were convicted of murder by a jury on May 8. The same jury declined to impose the death penalty. Those men are scheduled to be sentenced on June 22, leaving more legal business yet to be resolved in this tragic saga.
There’s an odd, exhausted rhythm to trials like this: evidence presented, public reaction amplified, a sentence rendered, and then more dates on the calendar. For fans and residents who watched the story arc unfold, Friday’s ruling is significant but not final. The sentences ahead for the other defendants will shape how this case is remembered — as a cautionary tale, a legal milestone, or something messier in between.
In the meantime, Judge Fernandez’s decision to deny the appeal motion and the 15-year term for Andrews stand as the immediate outcome of a case that began with a name on a night sky and ended with a mother’s plea in a small Florida courtroom.
